Company hires $15K “culture consultant” who recommends everything employees already said, then presents it back to them as a leadership breakthrough: 'I'm not even angry anymore I'm just tired'

Author image for Etai Eshet
Etai Eshet • Editor
Jun 9, 2026 11:15 AM EDT

Companies love solving problems the expensive way, especially when the cheap way involves actually listening to the people already in the room

This is a story about a workplace that had all the answers sitting right in front of them, handed over repeatedly and for free, and still needed to pay a stranger fifteen thousand dollars to say the exact same things in a nicer font before anyone took it seriously. That is not a communication problem. That is a credibility problem, and the credibility apparently costs fifteen grand to rent.

It's the classic hire person to do job then schedule meeting to talk about doing job then schedule another meeting to go over meeting about doing job then ask for agenda before meeting about meeting about doing job instead of letting do job then compline about no job being done so you end up paying 15 thousand dollars to a culture consultant, which is an obvious linkedin lingo made up title that trick company into paying you said 15 thousand dollars by the way. But that title is only a small part of the problem in this story, so I'll let it slide this time.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • Woman talking on the phone at a desk with a laptop and notebook in a home office.
    via Vitaly Gariev

    Illustrative photo of a model portraying an employee reacting to a workplace issue, talking on the phone at her desk.

  • So for context we're about 35 people, mid sized marketing agency, been through a rough couple of years with turnover. Good
    via prettyfaith2
  • people kept leaving, morale was noticeably low, and the general vibe had shifted from a place people liked coming to into something that just felt draining.
    via prettyfaith2
  • Multiple people including me raised this in one on ones, in the anonymous engagement survey, in a
    via prettyfaith2
  • team meeting where our director literally asked us what was wrong.
    via prettyfaith2
  • Woman in glasses working on a laptop at an office desk with a notebook and phone beside her.
    via Vitaly Gariev

    Illustrative photo of a model portraying an exhausted, bemused worker sitting at a laptop in an office.

     

  • The feedback was consistent and pretty specific. No clear path for progression, senior staff
    via prettyfaith2
  • taking credit for junior work, back to back meetings leaving zero time for actual output, and a
    via prettyfaith2
  • general feeling that leadership made decisions in a vacuum and announced them after the fact.
    via prettyfaith2
  • Nothing changed. We were told it was "being looked into."
    via prettyfaith2
  • Four months later they bring in an external culture consultant. She spent three weeks doing individual
    via prettyfaith2
  • Woman working on a laptop at a desk with a notebook, mug, and plants nearby.
    via Vitaly Gariev

    Illustrative photo of a model portraying a tired employee working quietly at a desk.

  • interviews with staff, ran two workshops, observed a few team meetings and then presented her findings
    via prettyfaith2
  • to leadership in this big formal session we were not invited to.
    via prettyfaith2
  • Last week they rolled out her recommendations in an all hands meeting like they were revelations. Clearer
    via prettyfaith2
  • progression frameworks. A policy change around meeting culture. A new process for project credit
    via prettyfaith2
  • and attribution. More transparency around leadership decisions.
    via prettyfaith2
  • Word for word what we had already said. Repackaged into a deck with her branding on it and
    via prettyfaith2
  • presented back to us as solutions our leadership had worked hard to develop.
    via prettyfaith2
  • The worst part is people were visibly nodding and saying it sounded great and I'm sitting there
    via prettyfaith2
  • thinking we handed them this information for free, repeatedly, and it meant nothing until a stranger
    via prettyfaith2
  • charged them $15k to say it in a nicer font I'm not even angry anymore I'm just tired
    via prettyfaith2

  • The whole consultancy industry runs on this engine. And cultural consultants (again, should not be a real thing). Not because outside experts are useless, but because a lot of organizations are just structurally incapable of hearing feedback from the people who actually work there. The same words land completely differently depending on who says them. Employees say it, and it becomes a complaint to be managed. A consultant says it in a formal presentation with branded slides, and suddenly it is a strategic insight worth acting on. Same sentence. Totally different font. Completely different outcome.

    What makes this situation so exhausting is how thorough the original feedback was. Not vague grumbling. Specific, consistent, repeated observations about progression, credit, meetings, and decision-making. Given in one-on-ones. Given in anonymous surveys. Given directly when leadership asked. And the response was being looked into, which in corporate speak translates pretty cleanly to we heard you, and we are going to do nothing until we find a more expensive way to arrive at the same conclusion.

    The all-hands meeting reveal is the real finishing touch. Leadership presenting the recommendations like they had done the hard work of figuring this out, with staff nodding along politely, while at least a few people in that room were sitting there doing quiet math on how many times they had already said all of this out loud.

    Anyone would be exhausted working in that kind of place because realizing that the place you work at has to outsource basic listening because it could not manage to do it internally, and that your input only counts once it gets laundered through someone with a deck and a day rate is, how should I put it? like adding a new character to the Sisyphus myth, say a cultural consultant who's dropped with her own boulder to the top of the hill while you watch your own roll to the bottom before starting all over again.
     

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

management workplace discussion employment issues boss workplace-stories hr coworkers
Scroll Down For The Next Article

Also From FAIL Blog

UPDATE: New employee decides to quit job after finding out they were hired to do a 3-person job that has nothing to do with their own role

UPDATE: New employee decides to quit job after finding out they were hired to do a 3-person job that has nothing to do with their own role

Trending Now

Man refuses to continue supporting 60-year-old mother after 18 months of doing so, leading him to question whether or not that was a good decision: 'The timeline I warned her about has now arrived.'

Man refuses to continue supporting 60-year-old mother after 18 months of doing so, leading him to question whether or not that was a good decision: 'The timeline I warned her about has now arrived.'

01
Boss demands employee 'evaluate' whether leading people is for him after getting too emotional in a meeting, employee is left wondering if he still has time to flip the script: 'Everything doesn’t scream trust. We have lost this trust in you.'

Boss demands employee 'evaluate' whether leading people is for him after getting too emotional in a meeting, employee is left wondering if he still has time to flip the script: 'Everything doesn’t scream trust. We have lost this trust in you.'

02
Empathetic Manager Pushes Back Against Leadership Who Refuse to Give Employees Raises: 'I went to my VP and I got laughed out of the room'

Empathetic Manager Pushes Back Against Leadership Who Refuse to Give Employees Raises: 'I went to my VP and I got laughed out of the room'

03
Employee quits job after getting verbal offer from another company, only to then be told the position got frozen and discover they hired someone else: ‘I don't know what to do’

Employee quits job after getting verbal offer from another company, only to then be told the position got frozen and discover they hired someone else: ‘I don't know what to do’

04
Homeowner calls cops on neighbor who cut down 11 of their 30-year-old trees: 'This is going to be very expensive for him'

Homeowner calls cops on neighbor who cut down 11 of their 30-year-old trees: 'This is going to be very expensive for him'

05
Vet office employee gets tired of hunting down coworker for handovers and starts leaving right on time, coworker runs to the boss to complain: ‘[It's not my business where you are in the building when your shift starts]’

Vet office employee gets tired of hunting down coworker for handovers and starts leaving right on time, coworker runs to the boss to complain: ‘[It's not my business where you are in the building when your shift starts]’

06
Advertisement